Skip to main content
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI 150th Anniversary
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI 150th Anniversary
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation (Sticky)

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • Marine Corps
    • Naval Intelligence
    • Naval and Maritime
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • U.S. Naval Institute Blog
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues
Sailors on the flight deck of the USS Paul Ignatius (DDG-117)
Sailors on the flight deck of the USS Paul Ignatius (DDG-117). Many junior sailors are reluctant to suggest innovations, lest their careers suffer for it.
U.S. Navy (Chris Williamson)

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • Marine Corps
    • Naval Intelligence
    • Naval and Maritime
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • U.S. Naval Institute Blog
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues

Conformity and Creativity in the Sea Services

By Airman Mark Tiu, U.S. Navy
April 2023
Proceedings
Vol. 149/4/1,442
From the Deckplates
View Issue
Comments

Pushing brooms, taking out the trash, and not questioning orders from higher ranks. This is the life of undesignated sailors. Creative ideas are above their pay grade. But does a culture of conformity help sailors thrive, or is it time for the Navy to push for disruption?

Spirit of Innovation

War has been the driving force behind many innovative ideas, such as computers, radar, global positioning satellites, and more.1 The urgency of war made the military laser-focused on concrete issues during times of conflict, and the generation that experienced these situations kept that mindset, focusing less on abstract problems. If a system is proven successful, why risk changing it? However, this mindset encourages newer service members to conform to old systems rather than bringing forward new ideas—even in the face of an increasingly complex and changing world. In a November 2022 Proceedings article, General David H. Berger, Commandant of the Marine Corps, noted simply: “The military cannot rely on yesterday’s solutions to solve today’s or tomorrow’s problems.”2

Conformity Before Creativity

Conformity does not necessarily inhibit creativity.3 In other words, before the Navy can spark positive disruption, it is important first to understand the cultural norms and practices that allow the Sea Services to function properly. Naval traditions exist for a reason and connect service members with each other and those who came before.4 However, there must be a line drawn between conformity and evolution. Status quo bias has been running the Navy for decades.5 In a 2007 essay in Armed Forces Journal, retired Army Colonel Paul Yingling stated, “It is unreasonable to expect that an officer who spends 25 years conforming to institutional expectation will emerge as an innovator in his late forties.”6 Such mindsets lead to complacency and stagnation, a deadly combination.

For an organization to remain relevant, it must be built on a foundation of conformity while allowing space for growth and creativity. The more sailors understand the Navy’s core values, the more they can change the service for
the better.

Recruits with the 64th Annual Recruit Cardinal Division
Recruits with the 64th Annual Recruit Cardinal Division during their graduation ceremony at Recruit Training Command, Great Lakes, Illinois. While it is important to understand the Navy’s traditions and expectations, sailors should have the space to bring new ideas forward. U.S. Navy (Aaron Lau)

The Private Sector

Successful business executives who served in the military, including Sam Walton (Walmart), Fred Smith (FedEx), Jack Taylor (Enterprise), Ken Hicks (Foot Locker), and Sam Shoen (U-Haul), prove that the armed forces have no problem recruiting men and women with great potential for leadership and a talent for devising disruptive ideas.7 The problem lies in retaining those individuals. In a culture of conformity, disruptive ideas are frequently ostracized, and those with a talent for them often end up in the private sector.

Furthermore, the private sector has embraced creative ideas for retention while the armed forces rely on bonuses and marketing themes that do not resonate as strongly with the current generation. Those who stay in the armed forces largely accept the status quo. While this has its place, it pushes sailors constantly to compete for qualifications, awards, and promotion—often leading to hostility rather than collaboration. It also develops sailors who are reluctant to put forward innovative ideas, lest their careers suffer for it.

Leadership

In my short time in the Navy, I have witnessed many senior enlisted sailors and commissioned officers use fear to keep more junior enlisted sailors in line. Fear-based leadership simply does not work in the long term, leading to the following problems: decreased cognitive ability; resentment; insecurity; fight or flight instincts; and disengagement from the team.8 The pressure put on these leaders to succeed makes them unapproachable with abstract issues, leading to poor management and loss of connection with subordinates.

However, it is not difficult to find new ways to look at leadership. As Army First Sergeant Bryant Gray stated in an interview on compassionate leadership, “You must be able to lead your soldiers and staff with the same care and compassion you would have with your own family.”9 Leading with fear is effective in the short term because it is quick, but it does not develop innovative, professional sailors who stay in the Navy.

Looking to the Future

Shared purpose, conformity, regulation, and uniformity are the foundation of military service, but retaining the best and brightest people beyond their initial terms of service will require a culture that encourages creativity, flexibility, and new ideas. The Navy need not look far for new ideas. Many sailors have the drive and desire to contribute to the Sea Services, but if the culture does not embrace them, they will take those ideas elsewhere.

1. RADM John W. Tammen, USN (Ret.), “NATO’s Warfighting Capstone Concept: Anticipating the Character of War,” NATO Review, 9 July 2021.

2. Gen David H. Berger, USMC, “Recruiting Requires Bold Changes,” U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings 148, no. 11 (November 2022).

3. Ella Miron-Spektor, Miriam Erez, and Eitan Naveh, “To Drive Creativity, Add Some Conformity,” Harvard Business Review 90, no. 3 (March 2012).

4. Kelsea Willenbrock, “The Value of Tradition,” Baylor Lariat, 28 November 2016.

5. Richard J. Zeckhauser and William Samuelson, “Status Quo Bias in Decision-Making,” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1, no. 1 (February 1988), 7–59.

6. COL Paul Yingling, USA (Ret), “A Failure in Generalship,” Armed Forces Journal, 1 May 2007.

7. James Rosebush, “Do Veterans Make Better Business Leaders and CEOs?” Real Leaders, 1 November 2021.

8. Andre L. Revell II, “Compassionate Leadership,” Army.mil, 18 June 2018.

9. Derek Gaunt, “Five Reasons Fear-Based Leadership Is Ineffective,” The Black Swan Group blog, 7 September 2020.

Airman Mark Tiu, U.S. Navy

Airman Tiu is an undesignated sailor currently attached to the USS Iwo Jima (LHD-7) Air Department. He joined the Navy in May 2021. He holds a doctorate degree in physical therapy from the University of Montana.

More Stories From This Author View Biography

Related Articles

Marines
P From the Deckplates

Encourage Enlisted Education Beyond College

By Corporal Madison Minner, U.S. Marine Corps
March 2023
Enlisted service members are hungry not just for education, but also for personal and professional development.
A sailor reading in the USS Abraham Lincoln (CVN-72) library
P From the Deckplates

Improve Guided Reading Programs

By Senior Chief Petty Officer Ross C. Wilson, U.S. Navy
February 2023
A system tailored to recommend books relevant to specific job roles, situations, and seniority would better guide service members
Marines
P From the Deckplates

The Coast Guard Must Adopt the Physical Fitness Test

By Petty Officer Third Class Zachary Reuther, U.S. Coast Guard
January 2023
The Coast Guard remains the only military branch to not hold its members accountable for physical fitness.

Quicklinks

Footer menu

  • About the Naval Institute
  • Books & Press
  • Naval History Magazine
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Oral Histories
  • Events
  • Naval Institute Foundation
  • Photos & Historical Prints
  • Advertise With Us
  • Naval Institute Archives

Receive the Newsletter

Sign up to get updates about new releases and event invitations.

Sign Up Now
Example NewsletterPrivacy Policy
USNI Logo White
Copyright © 2023 U.S. Naval Institute Privacy PolicyTerms of UseContact UsAdvertise With UsFAQContent LicenseMedia Inquiries
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
Powered by Unleashed Technologies
×

You've read 1 out of 5 free articles of Proceedings this month.

Non-members can read five free Proceedings articles per month. Join now and never hit a limit.