Skip to main content
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation (Sticky)

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • Innovation for Sea Power
    • Marine Corps
    • Naval Intelligence
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues
Coast Guard officer promotion ceremony
Coast Guard officer evaluation reports (OERs) could be improved if they emphasized different competencies and traits at different ranks throughout an officer's career.
U.S. Coast Guard (Ryan Dickinson)

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • Innovation for Sea Power
    • Marine Corps
    • Naval Intelligence
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues

Overhaul Coast Guard Officer Evaluations

By Commander Lushan Hannah, U.S. Coast Guard
March 2020
Proceedings
Vol. 146/3/1,405
Now Hear This
View Issue
Comments

Coast Guard officer evaluation reports (OERs) compare commissioned officers to an established standard, independent of any colleague at their unit or within their specialty. These evaluations assess traits, accomplishments, and behaviors through 18 performance dimensions using behaviorally anchored rating scales (BARS) with ranges of one to seven. The problem is that these performance dimensions are the same for every pay grade and do not accurately convey the varying levels of responsibility, technical expertise, and impact on the service that change with each pay grade. 

The 18 dimensions also do not align with the Coast Guard’s 28 leadership competencies promulgated in Commandant’s Instruction M5351.3. In 2018, the Coast Guard revised enlisted evaluations into a gradient of performance standards specific to each pay grade, providing higher performance expectations after each advancement. It also aligned these evaluations with the Coast Guard’s Leadership Development Framework. Now it is time for the Coast Guard to do the same with OERs.

The Coast Guard found that enlisted performance standards did not optimally support enlisted members and the various human resource decisions that impacted their careers. This included advancements, assignments, high-year tenure/retention, and special screening panels. A work group was chartered to revise enlisted evaluations to make them: an effective expectations management tool for enlisted members, a better performance management tool for supervisors, and a better talent management tool for the organization. In addition to aligning with the 2006 Leadership Development Framework, the revised enlisted evaluations now provide improved data for human resources staff at Coast Guard Headquarters and commanding officers and officers-in-charge to make better personnel decisions. Lastly, the revisions reduced the evaluation process workload by streamlining unnecessary competencies, while maintaining the effectiveness and value of the evaluation. 

Using a progressive scale of competencies, OERs should leverage the Coast Guard's 28 leadership competencies, which are grouped into four categories: Leading Self, Leading Others, Leading Performance and Change, and Leading the Coast Guard. Various dimensions could be added or replaced on each subsequent OER as a member increases in rank. This would better align with the mid-grade officer and civilian career transition course, senior leadership principles and skills course, and other training. Updated OER rating scales could serve as a clearer benchmark for officers who invest in their own professional development and look out on the horizon for what will be required of them at higher pay grades. Chapter 1 of Instruction M5351.3 best supports this argument with the following:

"Leadership is the ability to influence others to obtain their obedience, respect, confidence, and loyal cooperation. Good leadership develops through a never-ending process of self-study, education, training, experience, observation, and emulation. To assist members/employees in developing their leadership abilities, the Coast Guard has developed a leadership and professional development framework constructed around three components: (1) the Coast Guard’s twenty-eight leadership competencies, (2) the responsibility levels of members/employees, together with the expertise in each competency required at each level of responsibility, and (3) methods for gaining and demonstrating competency."

Starting with the O-1/O-2 OERs, the seven competencies under "Leading Self" plus two additional competencies from "Leading Others" should be sufficient. The number of competencies in higher pay grades from "Leading Others", Leading Performance and Change", and "Leading the Coast Guard" could be added on subsequent OERs. As you go higher in the organization, you would see less of the "Leading Self” competencies so that the total number of performance dimensions for each pay grade would remain optimal. However, by the time you reach O-6, your entire record would have captured your performance and growth across all 28 leadership competencies. The end result should be a clearer picture of the traits/growth needed to select future executive leaders. Along the way, this thoughtful approach to evaluations could better inform promotion boards, assignment officers, and supervisors. 

The Coast Guard Authorization Act of 2018, Section 803(d), required the service to survey officers to determine the amount of time each member of the rating chain spends on the OER. The results of that study have not yet been made public, but they should inform any changes to officer evaluations. The Coast Guard has an opportunity and a need to adjust course on OERs. It could not have come at a better time—now.

Commander Lushan Hannah, U.S. Coast Guard

Commander Hannah is the commanding officer of the Pacific Strike Team. His active duty Coast Guard career spans 21 years conducting marine environmental protection, commercial vessel compliance, contingency planning, law enforcement and search & rescue. He holds a Master of Science in environmental management from the University of Maryland–University College, a Master of Public Health in industrial hygiene from the University of Michigan, and a Master of Arts in national security and strategic studies from the Naval War College.

More Stories From This Author View Biography

Related Articles

A U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Tahoma (WMEC-908) boat crew participates in a search-and-rescue exercise off Greenland.
Commentary

Applying Bloom’s Taxonomy to Coast Guard Talent Management

By Petty Officer Andrew S. Burgard, U.S. Coast Guard
September 2020
The Coast Guard’s enlisted evaluation system does not do a good job measuring critical thinking skills.
A second-class petty officer on board the USCGC Hamilton (WMSL-753) trains a fire-attack team after a damage control exercise. Leadership training earlier in the training pipeline would net more petty officers who are self-reflective leaders, capable of performing high-risk evolutions with increased autonomy.
P Leadership Forum

Petty Officers Are Leaders, Too

By Ensign Logan James Tobias, U.S. Coast Guard
October 2023
The Coast Guard must begin championing the leadership development of its petty officers.
USCG Officer PQS
Commentary

Coast Guard Officers Need a 360-degree Evaluation System

By Lieutenant Ian A. Oviatt, U.S. Coast Guard
August 2019
A 360-degree feedback system will give officers an honest assessment of their strengths and weaknesses. And it can be implemented in a careful way.

Quicklinks

Footer menu

  • About the Naval Institute
  • Books & Press
  • Naval History
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Oral Histories
  • Events
  • Naval Institute Foundation
  • Photos & Historical Prints
  • Advertise With Us
  • Naval Institute Archives

Receive the Newsletter

Sign up to get updates about new releases and event invitations.

Sign Up Now
Example NewsletterPrivacy Policy
USNI Logo White
Copyright © 2025 U.S. Naval Institute Privacy PolicyTerms of UseContact UsAdvertise With UsFAQContent LicenseMedia Inquiries
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
Powered by Unleashed Technologies
×

You've read 1 out of 5 free articles of Proceedings this month.

Non-members can read five free Proceedings articles per month. Join now and never hit a limit.