Skip to main content
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI 150th Anniversary
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate
USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI Logo USNI 150th Anniversary
Donate
  • Cart
  • Join or Log In
  • Search

Main navigation (Sticky)

  • About Us
  • Membership
  • Books & Press
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Naval History
  • Archives
  • Events
  • Donate

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • CNO Naval History - Midshipmen and Cadets
    • CNO Naval History - Professional Historian
    • CNO Naval History - Rising Historian
    • Coast Guard
    • Enlisted Prize
    • NPS Foundation
    • Naval Mine Warfare
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • U.S. Naval Institute Blog
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues
U.S. Naval Institute Photo Archive
Running his ship aground did not end the young officer's career. He went on to receive 5 stars. The destroyer Decatur (DD-5), the ship that ran into a mud bank south of Manila, participates here in 1902 trials.
U.S. Naval Institute Photo Archive

Sub Menu

  • Essay Contests
    • About Essay Contests
    • CNO Naval History - Midshipmen and Cadets
    • CNO Naval History - Professional Historian
    • CNO Naval History - Rising Historian
    • Coast Guard
    • Enlisted Prize
    • NPS Foundation
    • Naval Mine Warfare
  • Current Issue
  • The Proceedings Podcast
  • U.S. Naval Institute Blog
  • American Sea Power Project
  • Contact Proceedings
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Media Inquiries
  • All Issues

Lest We Forget: ‘It is not in the stars to hold our destiny but in ourselves.’

By Lieutenant Commander Thomas J. Cutler, U.S. Navy (Retired)<p>
July 2012
Proceedings
Vol. 138/7/1,313
Article
View Issue
Comments

The proverbial stars seemed to be aligned for the young officer. After his graduation from the U.S. Naval Academy in 1905, he was posted to a brand-new battleship in the Asiatic Fleet, a plum assignment at the time. His early performance was so impressive that, as an ensign, he was given command of the newly commissioned gunboat USS Panay and simultaneous command of a small naval station in the Philippines, prompting him to describe his good fortune as having “one foot ashore and one at sea.”

Things continued to go well for the young ensign. When war briefly threatened with Japan in mid-1907, he was given command of the destroyer USS Decatur (DD-5). He overcame significant challenges in getting the ship ready for war in a timely manner and later successfully transported visiting Secretary of War William Howard Taft from Olongapo to Manila. It seemed apparent that the faith his superiors had placed in him was well-founded.

But then, on 7 July 1908, while entering Batangas Harbor, south of Manila Bay—an area known for unreliable charts—the young man was uncharacteristically careless. He estimated his position rather than taking bearings. When his leadsman suddenly reported that the ship was not moving, this promising young officer realized his stars had fallen from the sky. He had committed one of the potentially deadly sins of command­—running his ship aground, in this case, on a mud bank.

Attempts to free the ship by working her engines were fruitless and, although very much aware of his dilemma, he remembered his grandfather’s wise advice: “Don’t worry about things over which you have no control.” Escaping from that black night by going to sleep, he waited to see what the following day would bring.

Morning brought a change in fortune when a passing steamer gave a line and successfully pulled the Decatur out of the mud. The ship was saved and unscathed, but her commander was not. Following regulations, he dutifully reported the grounding and was soon relieved of his command.

It is worthy of reflection that this ship was operating in a remote part of the world, where communications were meager at best and scrutiny by higher command was all but nonexistent. With the support of a loyal crew, the young commanding officer might have been tempted to cover up the incident and, absent some other misfortune, might well have succeeded. But those same qualities that had prompted his superiors to invest their trust in him prevailed, and he chose not to compound his error but instead to face the consequences that his momentary carelessness had earned him.

A court-martial ensued, charging him with “culpable inefficiency in the performance of duty.” He was found guilty, and his promising career might well have ended then and there. But the court wisely chose to take into account the ensign’s previously flawless and impressive record and sentenced him only “to be publicly reprimanded by the Commander-in-Chief, U.S. Naval Forces in Philippine Waters.” The relatively light sentence was further abridged by permitting “the promulgation of these findings and sentence [to] be regarded as constituting in itself a public reprimand.”

Thankfully, the ensign’s career did not end there. Chester W. Nimitz would become one of the Navy’s greatest admirals. When he retired from active service four decades after the Decatur grounding, he did so with five stars on his collar.

*William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar

Lieutenant Commander Cutler is the author of several Naval Institute Press books, including A Sailor’s History of the U.S. Navy and Brown Water, Black Berets.

Quicklinks

Footer menu

  • About the Naval Institute
  • Books & Press
  • Naval History Magazine
  • USNI News
  • Proceedings
  • Oral Histories
  • Events
  • Naval Institute Foundation
  • Photos & Historical Prints
  • Advertise With Us
  • Naval Institute Archives

Receive the Newsletter

Sign up to get updates about new releases and event invitations.

Sign Up Now
Example NewsletterPrivacy Policy
USNI Logo White
Copyright © 2023 U.S. Naval Institute Privacy PolicyTerms of UseContact UsAdvertise With UsFAQContent LicenseMedia Inquiries
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
Powered by Unleashed Technologies
×

You've read 1 out of 5 free articles of Proceedings this month.

Non-members can read five free Proceedings articles per month. Join now and never hit a limit.