"The editors have done a commendable job of restoring Speiden's journal in a handsome format. They have reprinted a number of illustrations from that source, including several from Speiden's own hand. The editing has preserved the essence of the original writing, while removing some of the grammatical and stylistic infelicities. The notes are impressively-researched, and frequently quite helpful, especially in identifying personnel mentioned by Speiden." — International Journal of Naval History

"As with most primary sources, the journal of William Speiden is full of unanswered questions, partial observations and tantalizing hints of larger issues. But readers, whether those interested the maritime world of the mid-nineteenth century or in the history of US—Japanese diplomatic history, will find many nuggets in the work. — International Journal of Maritime History

"Those interested in the pre-Civil War Navy or American diplomatic relations with other countries should read this book." — The Journal of America's Military Past