Deal With the Next Threat

By Lieutenant Ryan "PC" Agte, U.S. Navy

Advances in Drone Technology

The capability of drone hardware is only getting better. Imagine a laptop with a transmitter similar to a basic remote control—except it can control four drones at a time, receive live video from each drone, and coordinate the movement of the drones using the GPS location of each device. Now, make the transmitter receiver on each of the drones a cellphone—something that can send and receive a small data stream over the internet. Finally, make the controller a computer that controls these drones over the internet and can handle the inputs of 50+ drones with object recognition software that can alert a user when any of the drones sees a contact of interest, like a naval vessel or a rotary wing aircraft. The elegance in a technology like this is that there is no advanced computing done on the drone itself, so the flying equipment is cheap and expendable.

The market for technology is increasing for commercial purposes, which will drive down the cost of acquisition by any party, malicious or not. As early as 2012, Vijay Kumar from the University of Pennsylvania did a presentation with the TED organization explaining advances in autonomous robotic flight and even their problem solving abilities in order to meet an objective. 1 In 2015, at another TED talk, Vijay Kumar explains advances in decentralized behavior where multiple drones work together to perform a task. 2 More familiar though is Amazon’s drone program in which they explain in a comedic video that they have drones that see and avoid technology and are able to fly 15 miles and deliver a payload. 3 This technology will continue to advance, paid for by consumerism. As the technologies continue to be produced on a larger scale, and are copied by other companies, market competitiveness will force the cost to consumers to plummet, making them accessible to anyone.

Repurpose Technology

This tech is the combination of a few well-developed technologies designed to counter U.S. military missions. When it comes to large-scale drone or unmanned aerial systems use, it would be difficult for any organization or government to hold a candle to the scale of operations being executed by the United States. However, the scope of U.S. missions is global and was designed to operate anywhere in the world. This is prohibitively expensive for most other parties, but if they only are concerned with drone coverage of a certain harbor, small island group, or a base of operations, it is attainable by organizations even less capable than the unstable governments of developing nations. This is where their advantage is revealed. If a small organization can organically create a network of drones that provide intelligence on U.S. military presence and operations, then the U.S. has lost the surveillance advantage and paid ten thousand time more to do it.

Worst-Case Scenarios

There are several doomsday scenarios that one could imagine with black skies filled with enemy drones, but here are a few that could have large impacts with at a low-cost to the enemy and are possible in current and future operating environments.

  • A large U.S. aircraft is on approach to an airfield where it will drop supplies. Somewhere in front of the runway a screen of 20 drones flies into the air at an altitude that the aircraft will have to fly through to make a safe landing. This could result in extensive aircraft damage and jeopardizes the crew and cargo.
  • A drone could fly a small explosive or chemical weapon and deploy it onto a U.S. asset with a payload delivery. One drone with a hand grenade could prove lethal for exposed individuals, but it would be unlikely to deliver a result that compromised the mission. If ten drones flew into the well-deck of an amphibious ship preparing for operations, however, the devastation could be far worse.
  • An ISR drone network could give the enemy a picture of the battlefield the U.S. military thought was impossible. They are able prepare for U.S. actions—surprise attacks on the enemy turn into traps.

In any of these scenarios, the operators of the enemy drones likely will be able to take actions anonymously. If approached by a drone, a U.S. vessel likely will not know if it has hostile intentions, which has large implications when it comes to rules of engagement. This can be solved by allowing warfighters to strike earlier rather than later, but if they strike something that they should not, or they shoot at a drone in an area where they should not, there likely will be political ramifications. The drone operator, however, can force the United States into these situations with no fear of retribution, because they cannot be identified.

The Way Forward

Anytime a technology is developed, there is a counter technology not far behind; drones are no exception. Several companies have developed or are developing jamming devices and other equipment. However, the road from development to acquisition and deployment is long and complicated for the U.S. military. There also are laser technologies being developed that could take down a drone, and something as basic as shooting them with bullets from ships or crew-served weapons could work to mitigate this threat. However, expending ordnance or using lasers come with regulations, and the commanders in charge of these weapons have to accept risk of unintended retribution from other nations when using these types of equipment and weaponry. These are the types of regulations adversaries can use to their advantage.

As these threats materialize the U.S. military must adapt with technology and tactics. However the enemy’s ability to see our positions and movements before we would like them known may never be undone. 

Lieutenant Agte is the assistant air operations officer on board the USS George H.W. Bush (CVN-77). He is a MH-60S helicoptor pilot.  




Conferences and Events

Maritime Security Dialogue

Wed, 2018-11-28

Maritime Security DialogueThe Return of Great Power Competition and SECOND Fleet A discussion with VADM Andrew "Woody"...

Defense Forum Washington 2018

WEST 2019

View All

From the Press

10 December - Discussion

Mon, 2018-12-10

10 December - Discussion

Mon, 2018-12-10

Why Become a Member of the U.S. Naval Institute?

As an independent forum for over 140 years, the Naval Institute has been nurturing creative thinkers who responsibly raise their voices on matters relating to national defense.

Become a Member Renew Membership