Nobody Asked Me, But... Beards Can Save Lives

By Senior Chief Hospital Corpsman Brian Jacobson, U.S. Navy

A few months later, in Chattanooga, Tennessee, four Marines and a Sailor were gunned down by a U.S. citizen at two separate military installations. Peter Bergen of CNN news reported, “Nearly a third of the 119 Americans accused of plotting an attack inside the United States since 9/11 were alleged to have plotted to attack U.S. military targets,” adding “Thursday’s shooting would not be the first jihadist attack on a U.S. military recruitment office.”3

OLD Reasoning

In 1984, when Chief of Naval Operations Admiral James Watkins banned beards, the reasoning reportedly was based on implementation of the oxygen breathing apparatus (OBA), which was used fleet-wide when combating fires.4 The OBA mask had to seal to the face to prevent smoke and vapors from entering the user’s respiratory system. The surface fleet has not used the OBA for more than a decade, however, replacing it with a self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA). Because SCBA is a positive pressure system, it does not require the user to have a face-to-mask seal, which is why many firefighters across the United States are able to still maintain beards.

Force Protection

The Department of Defense already has taken some actions to protect service members while off base and off duty, as well as in combat areas.

In 2013, the Navy stopped requiring base stickers on vehicles. According to Captain Brett Calkins, Navy Region Southeast operations and plans officer, the change helps protect military personnel off base. “You really never know where and when you are going to encounter terrorism,” he explained. “Vehicle decals can be easily recognizable to those out there that would like to do our service members harm, so not having them on vehicles off base will help lower visibility.”5

It has become part of Special Forces teams’ protocols to adopt beards and longer hair to better blend with local populations. In Afghanistan, special operations teams feared that without beards they would “face a harder time getting taken seriously by local leaders they depend upon for intel about their bearded enemy, the Taliban,” according to a New York Daily News article.6 During operations in-country, beards and long hair, as well as wearing traditional Afghan clothing, helped operators blend in and be seen differently from the regular military.

These are steps in the right direction, but to maximize force protection more changes are needed.

Recommendations

Regulations need to be changed to allow male service members to blend into the civilian population as much as possible when out of uniform. Allowing men’s hair to be longer on top, eliminating the requirement for close-cropped sides, and once again permitting men to grow beards would increase their safety. After working hours, female service members can take down their required hairstyles, which helps them blend into the population again, but men do not have that same option and remain a target both in and out of uniform. The U.S. military is one of the last to maintain such strict hair and shave regulations; most foreign military services allow their male service members to more closely resemble those they are protecting.

Senior leaders are responsible for the safety of their personnel, and bringing beards back would be additional protection for our troops after they leave the base. Blending in with the rest of society would reduce their chances of being singled out by groups such as ISIL or even drive-by shooters based solely on appearance.



1. Jason Molinet,”ISIS Hackers Call for ‘Jihad’ against U.S. Military,” New York Daily News, 21 March 2015.

2. R Wilking, “ ISIS Releases ‘Hit List of U.S. Military Personnel ,’ Claims Hacking Victory,” RT.com, 12 August 2015

3. Peter Bergen, “ Chattanooga Shooting: History of Attacks on U.S. military ,” CNN.com, 17 July 2015

4. “ A Brief History of Grooming in the U.S. Navy ,” USNI News, 23 October 2014.

5. Greg Johnson, “ Navy to Waive Vehicle Decal Requirements ,” Military.com, 13 June 2013.

6. James Gordon Meek, “U.S. Special Forces Ordered to Shave Off Beards, Some against Command Because It Helps Relations,” New York Daily News, 8 August 2008.


Senior Chief Jacobson is senior enlisted leader, Naval Branch Health Clinic Bangor, WA.

 

 

 
 

Conferences and Events

2018 U.S. Naval Institute Annual Meeting

Wed, 2018-05-02

2018 U.S. Naval Institute Annual MeetingWednesday, 2 May 20184:00 - 5:45 p.m.Washington, DC The 145th Annual Meeting of the...

View All

From the Press

26 April - Presentation

Thu, 2018-04-26

28 April - Festival

Sat, 2018-04-28

Why Become a Member of the U.S. Naval Institute?

As an independent forum for over 140 years, the Naval Institute has been nurturing creative thinkers who responsibly raise their voices on matters relating to national defense.

Become a Member Renew Membership