From the Deckplates

By Senior Chief Jim Murphy, U.S. Navy (Retired)

Military members staying on base are also less likely to get in trouble. Club managers used to have a strong connection with all levels of military leadership that was understood and respected by junior members. Additionally, there is significantly less chance that undesirable characters and illicit substances, both of which are common in and around civilian establishments, will be introduced on base.

There always will be disciplinary issues, but infractions on base are typically handled at much lower levels and without involving civilian law-enforcement. Forcing people off base to find entertainment leads to more frequent and more severe violations—circumstances bad for the individual and the command.

There are many reasons for the demise of base clubs, MWR mismanagement among them. Also responsible is the hypersensitive, politically correct, anti-alcohol climate since Tailhook, and the inappropriate military drinking age.

It’s a valid argument that Americans old enough and willing to serve are old enough to drink, and U.S. law supports this notion. Title 10 U.S. Code sets the military drinking age at 21, but with exceptions. One might think the drinking age only varies outside the United States, but there are situations where it can be lowered here at home, lower even than the drinking age of the state where a base is located. Common sense demands that if some military members under 21 are responsible enough to consume alcohol, then they all are. Varying drinking-age rules send military professionals mixed signals and lead to them being treated differently according to duty station or liberty port.

There are other good reasons to lower the drinking age, particularly because the current minimum actually works against the Navy’s Right Spirit campaign. Choose Responsibility’s Web site ( provides both sides of this argument. One of the most important facts discussed is that while the United States has the highest drinking age of countries surveyed, it has a “higher rate of dangerous intoxication occasions” than countries with lower or no minimum drinking age. Statistics prove that “[under] the 21 year-old drinking age, fewer underage individuals are drinking, but those who do choose to drink are drinking more, are drinking in ways that are harmful to their health, and engaging in behaviors that have a negative impact on the community.”

Proof that a lower drinking age works is found in Captain J. M. van Tol’s May 2008 Proceedings article “Worse Than a Crime–A Mistake.” The article highlights several inane Navy liberty policies and is worthy of serious consideration. One of Captain van Tol’s endnotes discusses a policy of matching his crew’s drinking age to that of the ports they visited. He instituted this policy without “worry or regret,” and other leaders can, too.

The Right Spirit campaign is worthwhile and important, but overzealous efforts to deglamorize alcohol have unnecessarily demonized it, even though alcohol is, for the most part, used responsibly and without incident. Statistics and experience prove that the services could lower the rate of alcohol-related problems by lowering the drinking age—supporting Right Spirit’s goal of eliminating dangerous behavior—while preparing currently underage Sailors for situations where they can drink legally.

Military professionals deserve fun and safe entertainment options, with and without alcohol. Revitalizing the clubs will bring ’em back on base, increase safety, and reduce disciplinary issues. In this case, Choose Responsibility’s motto is instructive: balance, maturity, common sense.


Senior Chief Murphy transferred to the Fleet reserve on 31 December 2008 after 21 years of active service. He served his entire career in the cryptologic community and was a qualified submariner.

Senior Chief Murphy will transfer to the fleet reserve on 31 December 2008 after more than 21 years of active duty.

More by this Author

None found for this author.

Events and Conferences

None found for this author.


Conferences and Events

Maritime Security Dialogue

Mon, 2016-06-13

You are cordially invited to: U.S. Coast Guard Update A discussion with: Admiral Paul F. Zukunft, USCG25th Commandant of the U.S...

2016 Naval History Conference

View All

From the Press

Keynote Speaker & Book Signing

Mon, 2016-05-30

Why Become a Member of the U.S. Naval Institute?

As an independent forum for over 135 years, the Naval Institute has been nurturing creative thinkers who responsibly raise their voices on matters relating to national defense.

Become a Member Renew Membership